Doodad Kind of Town

Thoughts on the AFI Life Achievement Award
November 28, 2007, 10:30 pm
Filed under: Mike Nichols, Woody Allen

It won’t happen till June, but the American Film Institute is giving its next Lifetime Achievement award to Warren Beatty. That’s certainly fitting enough – Beatty has a distinguished career of over 40 years as an actor, director, screenwriter and producer.

But looking over the list of those who have received the honor in the last 35 years (the first award was bestowed to John Ford in 1973), I felt some disappointment. (See the complete list here.)

The AFI never got around to honoring many of the deserving film artists before they shuffled off this mortal coil. Among those passed over (all of whom were still alive when the awards were started): Howard Hawks, Charlie Chaplin, George Cukor, Vincente Minnelli, Robert Altman, John Wayne, Katherine Hepburn, Audrey Hepburn, Cary Grant. (Although I recall hearing or reading somewhere that Grant was offered the award, but declined it. Something about being embarrassed by the idea of a staged tribute.)

The criteria for the Lifetime Achievement award are that”the recipient should be one whose talent has in a fundamental way advanced the film art; whose accomplishment has been acknowledged by scholars, critics, professional peers and the general public; and whose work has stood the test of time.” In 1993, the criteria was expanded to include “individuals with active careers and work of significance yet to be accomplished. “

Well, that explains Tom Hanks. He got the award in 2002, at the ripe old age of 47 (!) Speaking as 47-year-old myself, there is no freakin’ way that a 47-year-old needs any damn lifetime achievement award! Don’t get me wrong – Tom Hanks is a legend in his own time – but that award could easily have waited another 20 years. Ditto Steven’s Spielberg’s award in 1995. At a mere 49, and with “Saving Private Ryan,” “Munich,” and God knows what else still ahead of him, he was no candidate for lifetime achievement honors either.

Of course, it could be a very engrossing parlor game for movie buffs to pick their own Lifetime Achievement winners (or quibble with the existing list – and I think I can make a pretty strong case against the inclusion of Sean Connery, the 2006 honoree). In that spirit, I hereby submit my highly personal shortlist for the American Film Institute Lifetime Achievement awards. I don’t believe any one of them is under 65.

1. Shirley MacLaine – In a career than spans over 50 years, Shirley has grown up on screen from a kooky, red-haired gamine to a salty-tongued grandma; she’s never once given a bad or boring performance in the process. She’s worked with the greats and the near greats, from Jack Lemmon to the Rat Pack, from Alfred Hitchcock to Billy Wilder to Bob Fosse. Her roles in “The Apartment,” “Some Came Running,” “Irma La Douce,” “Sweet Charity,” “Terms of Endearment,” “Postcards from the Edge” and many others are classic. And that’s just in this lifetime! She’s still a little kooky, but she’s formidable – and, at 74, she’s due for the honor.

2. Stanley Donen – He was choreographing MGM musicals when he was barely out of his teens. Before he was 30, he’d revolutionized the film musical, directing “On the Town,” “Royal Wedding” (where he devised a way to make Fred Astaire dance on the ceiling) and “Singin’ in the Rain” – after 55 years, still the greatest movie musical of all time. His subsequent career included classic romantic comedies like “Charade,” “Indiscreet,” and “Two for the Road.” Donen is 83 and hasn’t made a theatrical release in over 25 years – but on the basis of his early career alone, he belongs in this pantheon.

3. Mike Nichols –
I can’t think of another director whose films are so consistently smart, sharp and uniformly well-acted. With a 41-year career that includes “The Graduate,” “Carnal Knowledge,” “Silkwood,” “Working Girl,” “Postcards from the Edge,” “The Birdcage,” “Primary Colors,” and the brilliant television adaptations of “Wit” and “Angels in America,” 75-year old Nichols is way overdue for this honor.

4. Francis Ford Coppola – Yes, you read that right. I scanned the list several times, and he’s not on it. And yes, most of his fellow seventies wunderkind directors are there (Spielberg, Lucas, Scorsese). If he’d only made the first two “Godfather” movies and “Apocalypse Now,” he’d still belong on the list, and at 68, he’s certainly old enough to qualify.

5. Jane Fonda – Ok, she’s GOT to be on a shortlist somewhere. In one career, she’s gone from cute comic ingenue (“Barefoot in the Park,” “Cat Ballou”) to sex kitten (“Barbarella”) to impressive serious actress (“They Shoot Horses, Don’t They,” “Klute,” “Julia,” “On Golden Pond”) back to comedy (“Nine to Five” and recently, unfortunately, “Monster in Law” and “Georgia Rule”)- and covered everything in between. Not to mention, if she gets the honor, it’ll be the first father-daughter dual win in the award’s history (pop Henry Fonda won in 1978).

6. Robert Redford – And he’s already got to be on the shortlist, too. I mean, c’mon! His classic acting roles (“Butch Cassidy and the Sundance Kid,” “The Way We Were,” “Jeremiah Johnson,” “All the President’s Men,” “Out of Africa,” “The Natural”) and distinguished directing efforts (“Ordinary People,” “Quiz Show,” “A River Runs Through It”) would be enough to earn him the honor. But he also founded the Sundance Institute for independent filmmaker, which already got him an honorary Oscar in 2002. Incidentally, he’s a little crinklier, but still cute at 71.

7. Woody Allen – Ok, I saved my most questionable choice for last. His work certainly has advanced the art of film, and most of his pre-1989 output has indeed withstood the test of time. (It’s not like nobody on the actual winners’ list has any clunkers on their resume.) In my mind, just the combination of “Annie Hall,” “Manhattan,” “Purple Rose of Cairo,” “Hannah and her Sisters” and “Crimes and Misdemeanors” qualify the Woodman for lifetime achievement honors.

(Photos –,,

Leave a Comment so far
Leave a comment

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in: Logo

You are commenting using your account. Log Out /  Change )

Google photo

You are commenting using your Google account. Log Out /  Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )

Connecting to %s

%d bloggers like this: